How To Rate A Book

The most important part of any book review I write is the star rating. Regardless of how thorough and meaningful my review may be, some people won’t look any farther than the star rating. To be honest, that’s often all I look at before I read a book.

 how to review a book

If a book has 3 or more stars, I’m generally not swayed by reviews. If it’s a lower star rating, I definitely want to know more before I take the plunge.

Ratings alone won’t keep me from a book, but if I’m already predisposed in one direction, they are often the tie breaker.

Star ratings are less subjective and thoughtful than a fully written review. I love writing reviews, and I’m certainly not saying they aren’t useful.

When I write a full review, I’m comparing it to all the other books I’ve read in my life, and calling upon all my life experience – even if it’s not a conscious effort. I assume many other reviewers do the same, therefore no two reviewers are going to be coming from exactly the same place.

Going with the 5 star rating system utilized by Goodreads, here’s what each star rating means to me:

5 stars – It was amazing – This means a book was exceptional in every aspect. It’s extremely well written, tells a phenomenal story, and is a prime example of the genre. These are books I write separate posts about, or talk about all the time, and recommend to anyone who will list.

how to review a book


4 stars – Really liked it – A book with this rating is still a great example of its genre. Generally there’s something lacking to prevent it to be 5 stars. Usually it’s a fantastic story with less than exceptional writing, or vice versa. Often I’ll be thinking a book is wroth 5 stars and then the ending lets me down, so it’s bumped to a 4. These are books I’ll recommend often.

hjow to review a book


3 stars – I liked it – Most books I read fall into this category. This means I found it generally good, just not exceptional in any category. This is a book I enjoyed, and might recommend, if I think it will resonate with a specific person.

how to review a book


2 stars It was okay – This means I can’t quite say I liked the book, but I didn’t necessarily dislike it either. In this case, I didn’t feel any emotional connection to a book and wouldn’t recommend it.

how to review a book



1 star – I didn’t like it – Not many books fall into this rating. Many of the ones I choose not to finish will get one star. Usually I feel these books are poorly written.



I can’t tell you exactly how to rate a book, or write a review, since my reading history and life experience will likely vary vastly from yours. However, I hope the above can serve as guidance for recognizing where you’re “coming from” when rating a book.

I also want to stress that it’s totally okay to give a book a “bad” review. For the most part, I stay away from saying anything downright nasty about a book, and I never badmouth a writer (probably because I am one…) Giving an honest review, is not the same thing, and is not only acceptable but encouraged. Constructive criticism makes us better writers.

Does this advice for rating books resonate with you? Do you have your own criteria you use? I’d love to hear about it!




  1. Saskia van de Riet

    July 15, 2018 at 3:20 am

    Nice, concise, clear article. Never thought about star rating this way before. Thank for enlightening me!

  2. Ramona Mead

    July 15, 2018 at 5:06 pm

    Thanks for your feedback, I appreciate it!

  3. Maria

    July 15, 2018 at 6:23 pm

    I agree with your star rating system although, true, assignment of stars would vary depending on where the reader comes from. I have tons of books but am not a voracious reader like you. I almost always prefer non-fiction over fiction. Great rating system. Thank you for your post!

  4. Ramona Mead

    July 16, 2018 at 9:38 am

    Thanks for your kind words and for taking the time to read my post and comment. Besides just reviewing and recommending books, I like to look into how we relate to what we read based on our experiences. I believe finding the “right book at the right time” can be life changing.

  5. What Exactly Is Horror? – Ramona Mead

    July 25, 2018 at 6:11 pm

    […] regularly, part of the reason I enjoy writing about books is for the opportunity to explore how we all relate differently to the same content. Often, this can be explained by life experience. For example my friends who […]

  6. What I Read in June 2019 -

    July 1, 2019 at 10:39 am

    […] Considering my star ratings for this list made me realize I’ve never included those in my monthly reviews on this site! Starting this month, I’ll include those. […]

  7. What I Read in September -

    October 2, 2019 at 9:00 am

    […] so that’s where the difference comes in! And out of ten books this month, four of them were Five Star Reads, which is a great […]

  8. 5 Tips For Writing Book Reviews -

    March 5, 2020 at 2:30 pm

    […] I’ve written about this before. The star rating is probably more important than the actual review because it has more sway with readers. Your star rating goes in with everyone else’s to give the average that shows up alongside the book title. Everyone sees that, but not everyone scrolls through reviews. […]

  9. How to Review Audiobooks -

    July 6, 2020 at 1:56 pm

    […] posted a few times on the how and why of rating books and writing reviews. Those posts have been general in regard to the format of the books. Today, […]

  10. What I Read This Week: October 24, 2021 -

    October 24, 2021 at 2:11 pm

    […] Two and a half stars rounded up. This book was a slog with some really nice moments throughout. The premise is lovely and it’s what drew me in. Sara is a writer of greeting cards and coupons. When her mother’s dying wish is for her to write the last installment of her best selling book series, Sara is confused and doesn’t believe she can do it. This is a story about believing in yourself and about the power of having people around who believe in you too. It’s about family drama and secrets and how that impacts future generations. All of that stuff was interesting but it was bogged down in a really slow timeline. The entire book takes place over just a few months but it feels like years. If it had been about 100 pages shorter, it would have picked up the pace and made it more compelling. I listened to the audiobook and the narration was flat. I still recommend it for readers who enjoy slow paced, character driven stories. […]

Leave a Reply